Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsIntermediate
Question

How do US state tax rates and holding-company location affect the siting and valuation of subsidiaries?

Answer

ranges from 0% (e.g. South Dakota, Wyoming) to high single digits or more; deductible for federal purposes → all-in rate = 21% + state × (1 − 21%). Some states (e.g. Texas, Ohio, Washington, Nevada) use gross-receipts or margin taxes instead.

Where the tax falls: apportionment, not HQ location. Most states now apportion income on a single sales factor with market-based sourcing → state tax follows where customers are, not where the head office or plant sits. Moving the HQ alone rarely moves the tax.

$100m of apportioned EBIT taxed at a 6% state rate vs. 0% → 6% × (1 − 21%) = 4.74% → about $4.7m more net income per year.

  • US: the classic Delaware intangible-holding company (Delaware exempts companies that only manage intangible investments) has been largely neutralized by royalty/interest add-back rules and mandatory combined (unitary) reporting in many states
  • International: holdcos are sited for participation exemptions, treaty networks and no dividend withholding tax (e.g. the UK, Netherlands, Luxembourg, Ireland); Pillar Two's 15% minimum limits the benefit for large groups
  • Germany's municipal trade-tax multipliers are the European analogue of local rate variation

in carve-out valuations, compute a stand-alone tax rate from the target's own apportionment footprint and entity structure; do not assume the parent's blended rate.

Deep diveShow more details

"Value scales with (1 − t): at a 25% rate, every 1 pp of tax saving lifts unlevered value by about 1.3%, so a 1.5 pp structuring gain is worth roughly 2% of EV."