Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsIntermediate
Question

How do corporate and personal taxes enter the discount rate, and why do practitioners use the pre-personal-tax market convention?

Answer
  • Cash flows: unlevered FCF is taxed at the corporate rate on EBIT (NOPAT)
  • Cost of debt: the interest tax shield → after-tax Kd = Kd × (1 − t) in the WACC
  • Beta levering/unlevering: βL = βU × [1 + (1 − t) × D/E]

investors pay tax on interest, dividends and capital gains, so what matters to them is the after-personal-tax return. Miller (1977) showed personal taxes can offset part of the corporate advantage of debt. Some statutory regimes build this in, e.g. Germany's IDW S 1 "Tax-CAPM" (one named example):
```
CoE_after_tax = Rf × (1 − tp) + β × ERP × (1 − tp_avg)
```

  • tp: personal tax rate on interest
  • tp_avg: average personal tax rate on equity returns
  • The marginal investor is global and institutional (pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, mutual funds), often tax-exempt or taxed differently → no single personal tax rate exists
  • Observable market inputs (government bond yields, ERP estimates, comps multiples) are pre-personal-tax
  • Consistency: cash flows are measured before personal tax, so the discount rate must be too; an after-personal-tax model must tax both the cash flows and the rate, so it does not simply produce higher values
Deep diveShow more details

In M&A and IB work, use the standard pre-personal-tax CAPM with the marginal corporate tax rate. Personal-tax-adjusted models belong to specific statutory or court valuations; if a mandate falls under one, the prescribed method must be followed.