Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsIntermediate
Question

What are appraisal rights (e.g. Delaware DGCL §262), and what valuation risks do they create after an M&A closing?

Answer

stockholders who do not vote for a merger can ask the Court of Chancery to determine the "fair value" of their shares instead of taking the deal consideration.

  • Cash-out mergers, including short-form mergers under DGCL §253 (≥ 90% parent) and two-step tender offer mergers under §251(h)
  • Market-out exception: no appraisal for shares listed on a national exchange (or held by > 2,000 holders), unless holders must accept cash or other non-stock consideration

make a written demand before the vote, do not vote in favour, hold the shares through closing, petition within 120 days of the effective date. For listed shares the court dismisses claims below a de minimis threshold (> 1% of shares or > $1m of value) unless it was a short-form merger. Proceedings are often multi-year.

fair value as a going concern, excluding any value arising from the merger itself (synergies), and with no minority or marketability discount.

  • The court can award above the deal price, typically where the process was flawed or the buyer was a controller
  • Statutory interest accrues from closing at 5% over the Federal Reserve discount rate, compounded quarterly (the buyer can prepay to cut it off)
  • The award benefits only the dissenting holders who perfected their rights, unlike some civil-law regimes (e.g. Germany's appraisal proceedings, where an uplift applies to all bought-out minorities)

DFC Global (2017) and Dell (2017) gave heavy weight to the deal price after a robust, arm's-length sale process; Aruba (2019) awarded deal price minus synergies. Since then, awards at or below the deal price are common in clean processes, and appraisal arbitrage has declined.

Deep diveShow more details

"In controller take-privates or thin sale processes, budget for appraisal risk: deal-price deference is weaker and interest runs from closing. Buyers sometimes negotiate an appraisal-out condition capping the percentage of shares that may dissent."