Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsIntermediate
Question

How do change-of-ownership rules (e.g. US IRC §382) affect the value of loss carryforwards in a majority acquisition?

Answer

US: IRC §382

  • Ownership change: a > 50 percentage-point increase in ownership by 5% shareholders over a rolling 3-year testing period
  • NOLs are not forfeited but capped: annual limitation = equity value of the loss company immediately before the change × the IRS long-term tax-exempt rate (published monthly)
  • Continuity of business: if the business is not continued for 2 years, the limitation drops to zero
  • Built-in gains: a net unrealized built-in gain increases the limitation when gains are recognized within 5 years (a built-in loss is restricted in the same way)
  • Also caps carried-forward §163(j) interest; post-2017 NOLs carry forward indefinitely but offset only 80% of taxable income

UK: change-in-ownership rules (CTA 2010 Part 14)

  • Carried-forward losses are forfeited if there is a change in ownership (> 50%) and a major change in the nature or conduct of the trade within 3 years before to 5 years after, or if the trade becomes small or negligible
  • Separately, above a £5m allowance only 50% of profits can be sheltered by carried-forward losses

Germany forfeits losses on a > 50% transfer within 5 years, subject to a hidden-reserves (built-in gains) exception, an intra-group exception and a business-continuation election.

do not capitalize NOLs at full face value × tax rate. Model the annual cap and discount the usable shield.

equity value $500m × 3.5% = $17.5m usable per year × 21% = ~$3.7m tax saving per year, versus a naive one-off value of $75m × 21%.

Deep diveShow more details

"In an LBO, always run a §382 / change-of-ownership test in tax due diligence: model the NOL at its capped annual use, and show a 'lost NOL' downside case."