Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsIntermediate
Question
What is a tax group (US consolidated return, UK group relief), and what tax advantages does it offer groups?
Answer
US consolidated return (IRC §1501/§1504)
- An affiliated group: a common parent owns ≥ 80% of the total voting power and ≥ 80% of the total value of each member's stock (domestic C corporations)
- One federal return for the group → one member's losses offset another's profits; intercompany gains are deferred
- Pre-acquisition losses of a joining member are restricted (separate return limitation year (SRLY) rules and IRC §382)
- States vary: many require combined (unitary) reporting, others taxing entity by entity
UK group relief (CTA 2010)
- A 75% group: the parent holds ≥ 75% of ordinary share capital (directly or indirectly) and is entitled to ≥ 75% of distributable profits and of assets on a winding-up
- No consolidated return: each company files its own return, but current-year losses (and, since 2017, most carried-forward losses) can be surrendered to group members
- A separate 75% test applies for tax-free intra-group asset transfers (chargeable-gains group)
Other regimes
e.g. the Netherlands fiscal unity at ≥ 95%. VAT grouping exists in the UK and many EU countries (the US has no VAT).
Valuation implication
losses become usable immediately against group profits instead of being carried forward → a higher present value of the tax shield. For an acquisition, check whether the buyer can reach the grouping threshold and whether the target's historic losses are restricted (SRLY, §382, UK change-in-ownership rules).
Deep diveShow more details
Pitch tip
"Watch the thresholds in structuring: management or rollover equity that takes the parent below 80% (US) or 75% (UK) breaks the tax group, and with it the loss offset."