Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsAdvanced
Question
What are royalty- and interest-deduction limitations (anti-BEPS rules such as US §267A), and what are their valuation implications?
Answer
Purpose
anti-BEPS rules stop groups from stripping profit out of high-tax countries through deductible royalties or interest paid to low-taxed or hybrid recipients.
US:
- IRC §267A (2017): denies a deduction for interest or royalties paid to a related party under a hybrid transaction or hybrid entity, to the extent the payment is deducted in the US but not included as income abroad
- BEAT (§59A): a minimum tax on large corporations making significant deductible payments to foreign affiliates
- §163(j): net business interest deduction capped at 30% of ATI
EU:
- Interest and Royalties Directive (2003/49/EC): removes withholding tax on interest and royalties between associated EU companies (25% holding), subject to anti-abuse rules
- ATAD: interest-limitation rule at 30% of EBITDA (with a €3m de minimis option) and anti-hybrid rules (ATAD 2)
- Germany (named example): a royalty barrier since 2018 makes related-party royalties partly non-deductible where the recipient's IP regime is preferential (< 25%) and not compliant with the OECD nexus approach
OECD context
BEPS Action 5 requires IP boxes to follow the modified nexus approach (e.g. the UK Patent Box at 10%); Pillar Two's 15% minimum further reduces the benefit of low-taxed IP holdings for groups with ≥ €750m revenue.
Valuation implications
- Tax model: disallowed royalties or interest raise the effective tax rate → reduced FCF
- Legacy structures: IP-holding or hybrid financing set up before these rules must be reviewed and may need restructuring (exit tax and transition costs)
- LBO debt capacity: interest caps reduce the tax shield on acquisition debt
Deep diveShow more details
Pitch tip
"For IP-heavy targets (pharma, software), do tax due diligence on IP location and hybrid financing: disallowed deductions and Pillar Two top-ups flow straight into the tax rate."