Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsAdvanced
Question
How do fairness opinions and statutory or court valuations (e.g. Delaware appraisal 'fair value') differ from a market valuation?
Answer
Fairness opinion
a financial adviser's opinion to the board that the consideration is fair, from a financial point of view, to shareholders (or to unaffiliated shareholders).
- Not a valuation of the company and not a recommendation to vote
- Built on DCF, trading comps, precedent transactions, premia paid and LBO analysis → a football field that should bracket the offer
- Supports the board's process (US business-judgment / Revlon duties); FINRA Rule 5150 requires disclosure of adviser conflicts such as contingent fees. In the UK, Takeover Code Rule 3 requires the target board to obtain competent independent advice
Delaware appraisal "fair value" (DGCL §262)
- The going-concern value of the company, excluding value from the merger itself (synergies)
- Pro rata share of the whole company: no minority or marketability discount
- The court considers "all relevant factors" (Weinberger, 1983) and, after a robust sale process, gives heavy weight to the deal price (DFC Global, Dell) or deal price minus synergies (Aruba)
Deep diveShow more details
Statutory/court value vs. market value
- Market value: what a buyer actually pays, which can include a share of synergies and a control premium
- Statutory/court value: a standard of value defined by law or a professional standard, with prescribed assumptions (e.g. synergies excluded, no minority discount). Germany's IDW S 1, with a typified investor and an after-personal-tax CAPM, is one named example
- Keep the standards apart: "fair value" in appraisal ≠ IFRS 13 fair value (an exit price) ≠ fair market value for tax (hypothetical willing buyer and seller)
Example (illustrative)
unaffected price $40, stand-alone DCF $45, deal price $52 including about $6 of synergies → a court following Aruba could land near $46, below the deal price.
Pitch tip
"In take-private and squeeze-out mandates, the unaffected price and stand-alone DCF set the floor, and the offer should sit clearly inside the fairness range, backed by a clean process record in case of appraisal."