Module II· Valuation - Minority Protection & Jurisdiction SpecificsIntermediate
Question

What are the main hybrid securities (preferred equity, convertible preferred, PIK toggle notes), and how do you value each in the EV-to-equity bridge?

Answer

a security between senior debt and common equity, usually subordinated, with a fixed or accruing return and limited or no voting rights.

  • Fixed (often cumulative) dividend, liquidation preference, typically non-voting
  • Bridge: treat it as a debt-like claim → deduct at liquidation preference / redemption value plus accrued unpaid cumulative dividends (use market value if listed)
  • Accounting: under IFRS (IAS 32), mandatorily redeemable preference shares are liabilities; non-redeemable preference shares with discretionary dividends are equity. Under US GAAP, mandatorily redeemable shares are liabilities (ASC 480), and SEC registrants show shares redeemable at the holder's option as mezzanine (temporary) equity
  • Preferred plus an option to convert into common shares
  • Bridge: if in the money, treat it as converted (add shares to the diluted count via the if-converted method, no deduction); if out of the money, deduct it as preferred at its liquidation preference. Never do both
  • In PE/VC capital structures, value each class through a waterfall (participating vs. non-participating preference) or an option-pricing model
  • The issuer chooses each period to pay interest in cash or in kind (added to principal), usually at a higher PIK rate
  • Bridge: deduct the accreted principal (face value plus PIK interest to date); in an LBO model, forecast the accretion to exit
  • Valued as debt: discount at a YTM reflecting subordination; often issued at holdco level → structurally subordinated to opco debt
Deep diveShow more details

Germany's participation certificates (Genussscheine) are a profit-linked hybrid used by family groups and banks to raise capital without granting votes.

"Always ask what each claim is worth at exit: preferred at liquidation preference plus accrued dividends, PIK at accreted value, and converts on whichever basis gives the holder more."