Module V· Local GAAP vs IFRS in M&A AccountingIntermediate
Question

Which methods do you use to value intangible assets in a PPA, and when do you use each?

Answer

Under IFRS 13 / ASC 820, intangibles are measured at fair value (exit price, market-participant view). They are almost always valued with an income approach using Level 3 inputs. The main methods are:

  • Relief-from-royalty: brands, trade names, patents and technology. It values the after-tax royalties the owner avoids paying by owning the asset.
  • Multi-period excess earnings (MPEEM): the primary intangible, usually customer relationships or core technology. It uses cash flows attributable to the asset after contributory asset charges for working capital, fixed assets, workforce and other intangibles.
  • With-and-without: non-compete agreements and sometimes secondary customer relationships. It compares business cash flows with and without the asset.
  • Cost approach: replacement cost for internally used software or when the asset cannot generate income on its own.

Key judgements are useful life, attrition, discount rate (reconciled to WACC/IRR through a weighted average return on assets) and tax amortisation benefit. The goal is to separate recognisable intangibles (contractual-legal or separable) from goodwill. Assembled workforce is subsumed into goodwill. Practice guidance includes the International Valuation Standards (IVS 210), US Appraisal Foundation advisories and national guidance such as Germany's IDW S5.