Module V· Local GAAP vs IFRS in M&A AccountingIntermediate
Question

How does US GAAP (ASC 805) PPA differ from IFRS 3 PPA?

Answer

The two standards are largely converged: both use the acquisition method, fair-value identifiable net assets and do not amortise goodwill. The differences interviewers ask about are:

  • NCI measurement: IFRS 3 gives a choice for each transaction. NCI can be measured at fair value (full goodwill) or at its proportionate share of identifiable net assets (partial goodwill, so lower goodwill and NCI). ASC 805 requires NCI at fair value, so goodwill is always full.
  • Contingent consideration (earn-outs): both record it at acquisition-date fair value as part of consideration. If it is classified as a liability, it is remeasured to fair value each period through P&L, not goodwill. If it is classified as equity, it is not remeasured. The classification tests differ (IAS 32 vs ASC 480/815), so the same earn-out can land differently.
  • IPR&D: in a business combination, both capitalise acquired IPR&D at fair value. It is not amortised until completed (then amortised) or abandoned, and it is tested for impairment in the meantime. The contrast comes afterwards. US GAAP expenses later R&D spending (ASC 730), while IFRS capitalises development costs that meet the IAS 38 criteria. In an asset acquisition (not a business), US GAAP expenses IPR&D with no alternative future use immediately, while IFRS capitalises it.