What are directors' duties when a company nears insolvency (UK wrongful trading, Delaware, civil-law filing duties), and what do they mean for over-indebted portfolio companies?
Directors' exposure in distress depends on the legal system:
- UK — wrongful trading (Insolvency Act 1986 s.214): once a director knew, or ought to have concluded, that there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation or administration, they must take every step to minimise creditors' losses — otherwise the court can order a personal contribution. As insolvency nears, directors must weigh creditors' interests (BTI v Sequana, UK Supreme Court 2022). There is no duty to file.
- US — Delaware law and Chapter 11: no duty to file and no shift of duties in the 'zone of insolvency'; directors keep their fiduciary duties to the corporation and the business judgment rule applies. Once the company is actually insolvent, creditors gain standing to sue derivatively (Gheewalla, Delaware Supreme Court 2007). Chapter 11 is a voluntary tool: debtor-in-possession, automatic stay, DIP financing and cram-down.
- Civil-law filing duties (e.g. Germany): directors must file within fixed deadlines — 3 weeks after illiquidity, 6 weeks after over-indebtedness — with personal liability and criminal exposure if they miss them.
Why relevant for PE? Sponsor-appointed directors must avoid acting as shadow or de-facto directors, keep a documented solvency view, and use rescue tools early: a UK restructuring plan or scheme of arrangement, a US (often pre-packaged) Chapter 11, or an EU preventive restructuring framework.
Deep diveShow more details
| Aspect | UK | US | Germany (civil-law example) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duty to file | no | no (filing is a strategic choice) | yes — 3/6-week deadlines |
| Main director liability | wrongful trading (s.214), fraudulent trading (s.213), disqualification | breach of fiduciary duty (creditor derivative claims once insolvent) | liability for payments after insolvency onset; criminal |
| Main rescue tools | administration, scheme of arrangement, restructuring plan (cross-class cram-down) | Chapter 11 (DIP, automatic stay, cram-down), §363 sales | preventive restructuring framework, self-administration |
| Control during process | administrator (directors stay in a plan/scheme) | debtor-in-possession | court-supervised or self-administration |
- Continuing to trade and paying selected creditors without a documented solvency analysis (UK and German liability risk)
- Sponsors instructing management directly — shadow-director risk (UK) or equitable-subordination / lender-liability arguments (US)
- Waiting too long: rescue tools work best before liquidity runs out
Question: "What is your approach to looming insolvency?"
Answer: "First protect the directors: a rolling 13-week cash-flow forecast and documented board decisions — in the UK that is the wrongful-trading defence, in Germany it drives the filing deadline. Then pick the tool early: a UK restructuring plan, a pre-packaged Chapter 11 or an EU preventive framework, rather than a formal liquidation. The sponsor stays inside formal governance to avoid shadow-director exposure."