What are the ATAD rules and their US equivalents, and how have they changed LBO structures?
ATAD (the EU Anti-Tax-Avoidance Directive) is a set of EU rules against aggressive tax planning. ATAD I (2016, applying from 2019) introduced the 30%-of-EBITDA interest limit, CFC rules, exit taxation, a general anti-abuse rule and intra-EU anti-hybrid rules. ATAD II (2017, applying from 2020) extended the anti-hybrid rules to structures involving non-EU countries.
US equivalents (mostly from the 2017 tax reform):
- IRC §163(j): interest capped at 30% of adjusted taxable income — the counterpart of the ATAD interest limit.
- IRC §267A: denies deductions for related-party interest or royalties paid in hybrid transactions or to hybrid entities — the counterpart of the ATAD II anti-hybrid rules.
- BEAT (§59A): a minimum tax on large corporations (average gross receipts of $500m+) that make significant deductible payments to foreign affiliates.
- Subpart F and the GILTI regime: the US CFC rules.
a hybrid instrument treated as equity at the holding and as debt at the BidCo no longer produces a deduction without an inclusion — on either side of the Atlantic. Sponsors need genuine substance at the holding and clean instruments.
Deep diveShow more details
| Aspect | Before | Today |
|---|---|---|
| Hybrid PEC (equity at the holding + debt at BidCo) | deduction without inclusion | deduction denied (ATAD II / §267A) |
| Sponsor PIK loan via the holding | interest deductible | limited by the 30% caps and hybrid rules |
| Holding substance requirement | a "letterbox" often sufficed | resident directors, office, staff expected |
| Documentation | light | extensive (board minutes, local decision-making) |
holdings with genuine substance plus clean equity or plain debt instruments. The acquisition-debt tax shield is obtained at the operating level (tax group / US consolidated return), within the 30% cap. In US deals with non-US sponsors, BEAT and §267A are checked on intragroup financing.
Question: "How did holding structures change after ATAD II?"
Answer: "Hybrid instruments no longer create deductions without inclusions — ATAD II in Europe, §267A in the US. Interest is capped at 30% of EBITDA under ATAD and 30% of ATI under §163(j), and large groups paying foreign affiliates face BEAT. So today it is substance plus simple instruments, with the tax shield at the operating level."