Module I· Lease Accounting (IFRS 16 vs ASC 842)Basic
Question
What is the main difference between IFRS 16 and ASC 842 lease accounting?
Answer
| IFRS 16 (since 2019) | ASC 842 (US GAAP; public cos. 2019, private cos. 2022) | |
|---|---|---|
| Lessee model | Single model: almost all leases treated like finance leases | Dual model: finance leases vs. operating leases |
| Balance sheet | RoU asset + lease liability | RoU asset + lease liability for BOTH finance and operating leases |
| Income statement | Depreciation + interest (front-loaded total cost) | Finance: amortization + interest; Operating: single straight-line lease cost in operating expense |
| EBITDA | Lease cost excluded (sits in D&A and interest) | Operating-lease cost still reduces EBITDA |
| Cash flow | Principal in financing CF; interest in OCF or financing | Operating: all payments in OCF; Finance: principal in financing, interest in OCF |
| Exemptions | Short-term (≤12 months) and low-value assets | Short-term (≤12 months) only; no low-value exemption |
Consequence
- Both standards gross up the balance sheet, so the balance-sheet total and lease liabilities are broadly comparable.
- The P&L is not: for the same leases, IFRS 16 EBITDA and OCF are higher than under ASC 842, because US operating leases still run through operating expense.
Pitch tip
When comping an IFRS reporter against a US GAAP reporter, put both on the same basis: either deduct lease depreciation and interest from IFRS EBITDA (pre-IFRS 16 / 'EBITDA after leases'), or add back operating-lease cost to US EBITDA and include operating-lease liabilities in net debt. This is the classic cross-border comps trap.