Module I· Deferred Taxes (DTA/DTL)Advanced
Question
How do change-of-ownership rules limit a target's loss carryforwards when its shareholders change?
Answer
Mechanics
Change-of-ownership rules limit the use of loss carryforwards after a shareholder change — critical in any M&A deal with a loss-making target. The approach differs by jurisdiction:
- US (IRC §382): an 'ownership change' is a >50 percentage-point increase in ownership by 5% shareholders over a 3-year testing period. The NOLs are not forfeited, but annual use is capped at the equity value of the loss company × the IRS long-term tax-exempt rate. Net unrealized built-in gains can increase the cap; if the business is not continued for 2 years, the limitation can fall to zero.
- UK (Part 14 CTA 2010): carried-forward trading losses can be disallowed where a change in ownership coincides with a major change in the nature or conduct of the trade within a set window around the change.
- Germany (§8c KStG), as a forfeiture-style example: a transfer of >50% to one acquirer within 5 years forfeits the losses in full, subject to exceptions for built-in gains (hidden reserves), intragroup transfers and an elective continuity regime (§8d) if the business is unchanged and no 'harmful event' occurs.
M&A implication
When acquiring a loss-making target, a tax DD workstream tests how much of the NOL survives closing and how fast it can be used. The sell-side often argues optimistically (losses preservable), the buy-side is typically more conservative. For large NOLs the gap can be a material share of equity value.
Deep diveShow more details
Pitch tip
'The $25m loss-carryforward value in our valuation reflects the PV of the NOL usable under the post-closing §382 limitation, with a 60% probability weighting on the advisers' preservation view.'